По-русски

​More Metaphorically Than Literally

There is an argument going on in Saint Petersburg: will it be OK to add a new wing (of modern architecture) to the Dostoyevsky Literary Memorial Museum or is it only allowed to recreate the lost tenement house nearby? In this article, we are covering the preliminary concept of the museum building.

26 April 2018
Report
mainImg

Known around the world, an indispensable part of the Russian school program, and widely read in the western countries, the writer Dostoevsky spent most of his life in the tenement buildings of Saint Petersburg, which was a custom those days. The historians of his creative work name tens of addresses. However, there is only one memorial museum in the city – the house in which the writer lived the last years of his life and passed away – Kuznechny Alley 5, in the Kuchina tenement house. The entrance to the museum is situated on the corner from the Dostoevskogo Street, downstairs, through the basement floor. The flat itself is on the second floor, with a cast iron balcony, the museum’s theater occupying the basement and the first floor. The museum is extremely active: performances, thematic evenings, and master classes; in April-May, the museum saw six different exhibitions. Therefore, it comes as no surprise that it in a desperate need of extra space; so far, people of limited mobility simply have no access here, there are staircases all over the place.

Concept of developing the Dostoyevsky Literary Memorial Museum. View of the museum from the Marata Street © Evgeny Gerasimov & Partners
Entrance to the Dostoyevsky Literary Memorial Museum. Photograph by Alena Kuznetsova


In December of 2017, the director of the museum Natalia Ashimbaeva and the architect Evgeny Gerasimov, in collaboration with the businessman Andrey Yakunin (the son of the former head of the Russian Railways and a co-owner of the VIYM company) created a nonprofit foundation “Petersburg of Dostoevsky”. Andrey Yakunin handled the fundraising issues, Evgeny Gerasimov developed a concept of the new wing of the museum for free, and he is planning to complete the entire project also on a charity basis. The organizers stress that the project is a nonprofit one; the building will be handed over to the state. Donations are being collected; the approximate anticipated cost of the construction is 700 million rubles. In April, the architectural concept was approved by the Smolny.

The foundation is planning to build the new wing next to the museum: in 1971, to the left of it, a house was dismantled – it was a tenement building of pretty much the same kind, looking very much like the Dostoevsky museum – and there are plans for building the new wing in its stead; the size of the wing will be very close to that of the demolished house, meaning, it is practically going to be a regeneration project. The local preservation activists were vocally critical of the whole thing, specifically, on two points: first of all, the two lawns on either side of the driveway are inside the new construction blueprint. These lawns have already been excluded from the list of “public landscaped areas” but the critics of the project consider them to be a piece of parkland, while the director of the museum Natalia Ashimbaeva, on the other hand, claims that the formal size of a park, in accordance with the effective legislation, is 400 square meters or higher, and the lawns are smaller than that. The real little park with full-fledged trees will be preserved and landscaped inside the yard.

The current break in the stead of House #7 in the Kuznechny Alley / Photo courtesy Evgeny Gerasimov & Partners


The current yard of House #7 in the Kuznechny Alley. The tree on the right will be preserved / Photo courtesy Evgeny Gerasimov & Partners


The construction site of the new wing is marked in red. Concept of developing the Dostoyevsky Literary Memorial Museum. View of the museum from the Marata Street © Evgeny Gerasimov & Partners


Another, more interesting, issue is the modern style of the proposed architecture of the new museum building. Accusations came up to the effect that the project is “killing the Saint Petersburg of Dostoevsky” because it violates the fabric of the old houses in this area. Some people proposed to restore the house, which was torn down in 1971 and let it host the museum.

However, this solution is fraught with a few paradoxes, though predictable. First, the foundation wants to present the building with a museum, and, although, museums and nonprofit projects are usually a welcome thing, in this instance the public protests. Second, Evgeny Gerasimov, known as the author of many serious stylizations, wants to build a modernist building of the museum, and he is criticized for that. One more thing: competent architects would be unlikely to criticize their fellow colleague for such a solution because – and that’s important – unlike in the times of Roman Klein, who designed and built the State Pushkin Museum, today it is not a common standard to design museums in the style of historicism. True, there are exceptions, but these are few and far between, for example, the Museum in Yoshkar Ola.

zooming
National art gallery in Yoshkar Ola. Photo: Alkort via Wikimedia Commons. Lisense CC BY 3.0


The guarded attitude of the people of Saint Petersburg towards modern architecture is something that is widely known; a lot of people believe that in the context of the historical construction you can only build in the historicist style and stylizations in order to avoid violating the integrity of the city environment. However, on the one hand, over the last half a century we saw the forming of the notion of “environmental modernism”, the kind of architecture that is modern but still unobtrusive of its context and delicate enough to adjust its parameters (like height and proportions) to it, and rather neutral without being garish.

On the other hand, a museum is to some extent the paragon of modern culture, a place where it gives meaning to – and in many ways stresses – its difference from the culture of the past, setting itself against it and studying the true artifacts. While in the XIX century a museum would oftentimes use stylizations in order to immerse the visitor into the atmosphere of the epoch that it represented, becoming a theater of sorts, today the last thing that museums want is imitation. Everything that is new in a museum is ostentatiously new, any kind of stylization is perceived as a recently-hacked fake and an insult to the museum cause.

Evgeny Gerasimov has a few more arguments against repeating verbatim House #7 on the Kuznechny Alley. If this building is to be recreated to a letter, it will not be able to serve the function of the modern museum – at least because of the fact that most of its windows will be blind imitations because the two bottom floors (as is planned) will be occupied by the theater auditorium, whilst the two upper floors will be occupied by a lecture hall and a library. Out of the whole set of functions, only the exhibition premises need sunlight, and even these do not always require it. The second argument: the surrounding environment is historical and classicist, yes, it is true, but it does not at all belong to the times when Dostoevsky lived in the Kuznechny Alley! The “InzhEkon” building is neoclassicism of the 1910’s; the Kuznechny Market is the neoclassicism of the 1920’s. This argument, however, is but secondary; it is clear that what matters for the architect is the museum typology, which nowadays allows of no stylization whatsoever.

Evgeny Gerasimov gives examples of modern museum buildings: small, neatly inscribed into the city environment, merging with it in terms of scale and proportion, and not trying to conceal their age. One of such buildings is the Museum for Architectural Drawing in Berlin, founded by his long-standing partner Sergey Tchoban.

zooming
The Museum for Architectural Drawing © Patricia Parinejad


The Art Museum in Nantes, France © Hufton+Crow


zooming
Kunstgalerie Hinter dem Giesshaus © Ute Zscharnt for David Chipperfield Architects


Asian Civilisations Museum, Singapore © GreenhilLi


Probably, these examples, which helped the architect to place his idea into the context of the museum construction typology, are one of the main components of the concept.

Otherwise – Evgeny Gerasimov stresses – the project is but preliminary, “only a concept”; the inner organization is currently more detailed than the façades. “An active search for their design solution is underway” – the architect specifies. Therefore, one can only speak now about the “treatment of metaphorical meanings of architectural solutions” – the company states.

What is known as of this moment?
The contextual traits: leveling out the height of the building at the mark of the cornice of the old house; the slicing of the wall in accordance with the floors will most likely be preserved, just as the highlighting of the entrance by the vertical of the atrium.

The new wing will merge with the old building but at the same time it will be separated from it by an atrium that will on the inside look like a small dead-end alley with a panoramic elevator at its end and a stained glass window on the street side. “The atrium all about the image of the “water well” yard as the inside of the human soul where most of the writer’s novels take place – Evgeny Gerasimov explains – Dostoevsky would drag out into the light the darkest secrets of the human soul, which are usually hidden deep down inside, and because of that we bring the “water well” yard to the foreground” – the architect stresses. The windows of the two buildings – the old tenement and the new museum – are looking at each other over a narrow space of the atrium yard, giving the visitor a cramped feeling. There is a boardwalk between the buildings as the symbol of a transition, a “teleport”, a bridge between the old and the new or even the symbolic mirror between the museum house and its new reflection.

Concept of developing the Dostoyevsky Literary Memorial Museum © Evgeny Gerasimov & Partners


“The true memorial part of the museum will stay in the old building – the architect shares – And the new wing is meant to attract the readers of the new generations. There is Dostoevsky as a realist, and there is Dostoevsky as an innovator; his creative writing sort of was refracted through the prism of time. And we treat this boardwalk as a transition from one epoch to another, a metaphorical teleport, the atrium being the portal for leaping through space and time”.

Concept of developing the Dostoyevsky Literary Memorial Museum © Evgeny Gerasimov & Partners


Concept of developing the Dostoyevsky Literary Memorial Museum. Atrium © Evgeny Gerasimov & Partners


The façades are something that the architects prefer not to speak about – they say that they are not quite finished yet – but it is already clear that the laconic and modern solution become a point of honor for Evgeny Gerasimov. It must be said that this story with the project of Dostoevsky Museum is not the only example in the latest history of the Russian architecture when the public votes for the recreation of a lost building, while the architect votes for the up-to-date solution. Given the knowledge of Saint Petersburg conservatism, one could suppose that the concept is in for a lot of difficulties – but then again, any idea needs to be grounded and honed to perfection. What if when the project is ready its exquisiteness will win over its opponents and it will get Saint Petersburg closer to the view of the European capitals on the development of the city’s historical context, and will make possible a peaceful coexistence of the new and the old that only enriches the environment?

Currently, the foundation is settling the legal issues connected with the land plot. Next on the agenda are the project stage and its discussion in the Town Planning council and the Cultural Heritage Preservation Council. The construction is scheduled to begin in the first quarter of 2019.

26 April 2018

Headlines now
Resort on the Kama River
Wowhaus has developed a project for the reconstruction of Korabelnaya Roshcha (“Mast Grove”), a wellness resort located on the banks of the Kama River.
Nests in Primorye
The eco-park project “Nests”, designed by Aleksey Polishchuk and the company Power Technologies, received first prize at the Eco-Coast 2025 festival, organized by the Union of Architects of Russia. For a glamping site in Filinskaya Bay, the authors proposed bird-shaped houses, treehouses, and a nest-shaped observation platform, topping it all with an entrance pavilion executed in the shape of an owl.
The Angle of String Tension
The House of Music, designed by Vladimir Plotkin and the architects of TPO Reserve, resembles a harp, and when seen from above, even a bass clef. But if only it were that simple! The architecture of the complex fuses two distinct expressive languages: the lattice-like, transparent, permeable vocabulary of “classical” modernism and the sculptural, ribbon-like volumes so beloved by today’s neo-modernism. How it all works – where the catharsis lies, which compositional axes underpin the design, where the project resembles Zaryadye Concert Hall and where it does not – read in the article below.
How Historic Tobolsk Becomes a Portal to the Future
Over the past decade, the architectural company Wowhaus has developed urban strategies for several Russian cities – Vyksa, Tula, and Nizhnekamsk, to name but a few. Against this backdrop, the Tobolsk master plan stands out both for its scale – the territory under transformation covers more than 220 square kilometers – and for its complexity.
St. Petersburg vs Rome
The center of St. Petersburg is, as we know, sacred – but few people can say with certainty where this “sacred place” actually begins and ends. It’s not about the formal boundaries, “from the Obvodny Canal to the Bolshaya Nevka”, but about the vibe that feels true to the city center. With the Nevskaya Ratusha complex – built to a design that won an international competition – Evgeny Gerasimov and Sergei Tchoban created an “image of the center” within its territory. And not so much the image of St. Petersburg itself, as that of a global metropolis. This is something new, something that hasn’t appeared in the city for a long time. In this article, we study the atmosphere, recall precedents, and even reflect on who and when first called St. Petersburg the “new Rome”. Clearly, the idea is alive for a reason.
On the Wave
The project of transforming the river port and embankment in the city of Cheboksary, developed by the ATRIUM Architects, involves one of the city’s key areas. The Volga embankment is to be turned into a riverside boulevard – a multifunctional, comfortable, and expressive space for work and leisure activities. The authors propose creating a new link with the city’s main Krasnaya (“Red”) Square, as well as erecting several residential towers inspired by the shape of the traditional national women’s headdress – these towers are likely to become striking accents on the Volga panorama.
Valery Kanyashin: “We Were Given a Free Hand”
The Headliner residential complex, the main part of which was recently completed just across from Moscow City, is a kind of neighbor to the MIBC that doesn’t “play along” with it. On the contrary, the new complex is entirely built on contrast: like a city of differently scaled buildings that seems to have emerged naturally over the past 20 years – which is a hugely popular trend nowadays! And yet here – perhaps only here – such a project has been realized to its full potential. Yes, high-rises dominate, but all these slender, delicate profiles, all these exciting perspectives! And most importantly – how everything is mixed and composed together... We spoke with the project’s leader Valery Kanyashin.
​The Keystone
Until quite recently, premium residential and office complexes in Moscow were seen as the exclusive privilege of the city center. Today the situation is changing: high-quality architecture is moving beyond the confines of the Third Ring Road and appearing on the outskirts. The STONE Kaluzhskaya business center is one such example. Projects like this help decentralize the megalopolis, making life and work prestigious in any part of the city.
Perpetuum Mobile
The interior of the headquarters of Natsproektstroy, created by the IND studio team, vividly and effectively reflects the client’s field of activity – it is one of Russia’s largest infrastructure companies, responsible for logistics and transport communications of every kind you can possibly think of.
Water and Light
Church art is full of symbolism, and part of it is truly canonical, while another part is shaped by tradition and is perceived by some as obligatory. Because of this kind of “false conservatism”, contemporary church architecture develops slowly compared to other genres, and rarely looks contemporary. Nevertheless, there are enthusiasts in this field out there: the cemetery church of Archangel Michael in Apatity, designed by Dmitry Ostroumov and Prokhram bureau, combines tradition and experiment. This is not an experiment for its own sake, however – rather, the considered work of a contemporary architect with the symbolism of space, volume, and, above all, light.
Champions’ Cup
At first glance, the Bell skyscraper on 1st Yamskogo Polya Street, 12, appears strict and laconic – though by no means modest. Its economical stereometry is built on a form close to an oval, one of UNK architects’ favorite themes. The streamlined surface of the main volume, clad in metal louvers, is sliced twice with glass incisions that graphically reveal the essence of the original shape: both its simplicity and its complexity. At the same time, dozens of highly complex engineering puzzles have been solved here.
Semi-Digital Environment
In the town of Innopolis, a satellite of Kazan, the first 4-star hotel designed by MAD Architects has opened. The interiors of the hotel combine elegance with irony, and technology with comfort, evoking the atmosphere of a computer game or maybe a sci-fi movie about the near future.
History never ends
The old railway station in Kapan, a city in southern Armenia, has been given new life by the Paris-based design firm Normal Studio. Today, it serves as a TUMO center.
A Deep, Crystal Shine
A new luxury residential development by ADM architects is set to rise in the Patriarch’s Ponds district, not far from Novopushkinsky Square. It will replace three buildings erected in the early 1990s. The project authors, Andrey Romanov and Ekaterina Kuznetsova, have placed their bets on the variety among the three volumes, modern design solutions, and attention to detail: one of the buildings will feature smoothly curved balconies with a ceramic sheen on their undersides, while another will be accented by glass “sculpture” columns.
Grigory Revzin: “What we should do with the architecture of the seventies”
Soviet modernism came in two flavors: the good, author-driven kind, and the bad, standardized kind. The good kind was “on the periphery”, while the bad kind was in the center – geographically, in terms of attention, scale, and everything else. Can we demolish it? “That would be destroying public consensus out of thin air”. So what should we do? Preserve it, but creatively: “Bring architecture into places where it hasn’t yet appeared”. Treat these buildings not as monuments, but as urban landscape. Read our interview with Grigory Revzin on the pressing topic of saving modernism – where he proposes a controversial, yet really intriguing, way of preserving 1970s buildings.
A Roadside Picnic of Urban Planning Theorists
Marina Egorova, head of Empate Architectural Bureau, brought together urban planning theorists – the successors of Alexey Gutnov and Vyacheslav Glazychev – to revive the substance and depth of professional discourse. At the first meeting, much ground was covered: the participants revisited the theoretical foundations, aligned their values, examined a cutting-edge case of the Kazan agglomeration, and concluded with the unfathomable intricacies of Russian land demarcation. Below, we present key takeaways from all the presentations.
Perspective View
CNTR Architects has designed a business center for a new district in Yekaterinburg, aiming to reduce the need for commuting and make the residential environment more diverse. The architectural solutions are equally focused on creating spatial flexibility, comfortable working conditions, and a memorable image that could allow the building to become a spatial landmark of the district.
Malevich and Bathhouses, Nature and High-Tech
The Malevich Bathhouse complex is scheduled to open in the fall of 2025 on the Rublyovo-Uspenskoye Highway. The project, designed by DBA-GROUP under the leadership of Vladislav Andreev, is an example of an unconventional approach to the image of a spa in general and of a bathhouse in particular. Deliberately avoiding any kind of allusion, the architects opted for streamlined forms with characteristic rounded corners, a combination of wood with bent glass, and restrained contemporary shapes – both inside and out. Let’s take a closer look at the project.
Rather, a Tablecloth and a Glass!
After many years, the long-abandoned Horse Guards Department building in St. Petersburg has finally received the attention it deserves: according to a design by Studio 44, the first restoration and adaptation works are scheduled to begin this year. Both the intended function and the general scope of works imply minimal alteration to the complex, which has preserved traces of its three-century history. All solutions are reversible and aimed, above all, at opening the monument to the city and immersing it in a lively social scene – hence the choice of a cultural center scenario with a strong gastronomic component.
​Materialization of Airflows
The Nikolai Kamov International Airport in Tomsk opened at the end of August last year. We have already written about the project – now we are taking a look at the completed building. Its functionality is reinforced by symbolic undertones: the architects at ASADOV sought to reflect local identity in the architecture as fully as possible.
The City as a Narrative
Sergey Skuratov’s approach to large urban plots could best be described as a “total design code”. The architect pays equal attention to the overall composition and the smallest of details, striving to ensure that every aspect is thoroughly thought out and subordinated to the original vision. It’s a Renaissance-like approach, really – a titanic effort demanding remarkable willpower and perseverance. The results are likewise grand – architecture that makes a statement. This article looks at the revived concept for the central section of the Seventh Heaven residential district in Kazan, a composition so thoroughly considered that even the “gradient of visual emphasis” (sic!) across the facades has been carefully worked out. It also touches on the narrative idea behind the project – and even the architect’s own doubts about it.
A Garden of Hope for Freedom
In October, at the Spaso-Evfimiev Monastery in Suzdal, the Prison Yard Garden opened on the site that had served as a prison from the 18th century until the Khrushchev Thaw. The architectural concept was developed by NOῨD Short Film, and the landscape design by the MOX landscape bureau. In fact, there are two gardens here – very different ones. We try to understand whether they evoke the right emotions in visitors, while also showing the beauty of June’s ruderal plants in bloom.
A Laconic Image of Time
The Time Square residential complex, built on the northern edge of St. Petersburg, appears more concise and efficient than its neighbor and predecessor, the New Time complex. Nevertheless, the architect’s hand is clearly felt: themes of “black and white”, “inside and outside”, and most notably, the “lamellar” quality of the facades that seems to visibly “eat away” at the buildings’ mass – everything is played out like a well-written score. One is reminded of both classical modernism and the so-called “post-constructivism”.
The Flower of the Lake
The prototype for the building of the Kamal Theater in Kazan is an ice flower: a rare and fragile natural phenomenon of Lake Kaban “froze” in the large, soaring outlines of the glass screens enclosing the main volume, shaping its silhouette and shielding the stained-glass windows from the sun. The project, led by the Wowhaus consortium and including global architecture “star” Kengo Kuma, won the 2021/2022 competition and was realized close to the original concept in a short – very short – period of time. The theater opened in early 2025. It was Kengo Kuma who proposed the image of an ice flower and the contraposition of cold on the outside and warmth on the inside. Between 2022 and 2024, Wowhaus did everything possible to bring this vision to life, practically living on-site. Now we are taking a closer look at this landmark building and its captivating story.
Peaceful Integration on Mira Avenue
The MIRA residential complex (the word mir means “peace” in Russian), perched above the steep banks of the Yauza River and Mira Avenue, lives up to its name not only technically, but also visually and conceptually. Sleek, high-rise, and glass-clad, it responds both to Zholtovsky’s classicism and to the modernism of the nearby “House on Stilts”. Drawing on features from its neighbors, it reconciles them within a shared architectural language rooted in contemporary façade design. Let’s take a closer look at how this is done.
An Interior for a New Format of Education
The design of the new building for Tyumen State University (TyumSU) was initially developed before the pandemic but later revised to meet new educational requirements. The university has adopted a “2+2+2” system, which eliminates traditional divisions into groups and academic streams in favor of individualized study programs. These changes were implemented swiftly – right at the start of construction. Now that the building is complete, we are taking a closer look.
Penthouses and Kokoshniks
A new residential complex designed by ASADOV Architects for the Krasnaya Roza business district responds to its proximity to 17th-century landmarks – the chambers of the Hamovny Dvor and St. Nicholas Church – as well as to the need to preserve valuable façades of a historic rental house built in the Russian Revival style. The architects proposed a set of buildings of varying heights, whose façades reference ecclesiastical architecture. But we were also able to detect other associations.
Centipede Town
The new school campus designed by ATRIUM Architects, located on the shores of a protected lake in the Imeretian Lowland Ornithological Reserve, represents an important and ambitious undertaking for the team: this is not just a school, but a Presidential Lyceum for the comprehensive development of gifted children – 2,500 students from age 3 through high school. At the same time, it is also envisioned as a new civic hub for the entire Sirius territory. In this article, we unpack the structure and architecture of this “lyceum town”.
Warm Black and White
The second phase of “Quarter 31”, designed by KPLN and built in the Moscow suburb town of Pushkino, reveals a multifaceted character. At first glance, the complex appears to be defined by geometry and a monochrome palette. But a closer look reveals a number of “irregular” details: a gradient of glazing and flared window frames, a hierarchy of façades, volumetric brickwork, and even architectural references to natural phenomena. We explore all the rules – and exceptions – that we were able to discover here.