A Hard Luck Project

A story of a project based upon an equitable dialogue between a new building and the remodeled façade of a demolished tenement being able to maintain its right to sport the contemporary-style design in the new part of the building.

Written by:
Irina Bembel
Translated by:
Anton Mizonov

24 December 2015

The land site in question is located within the industrial park of the Petrograd Side, not far away from the old Tram Depot #3. Running in the vicinity of the Avstriyskaya ("Austrian") Square, the neat and tidy Mira Street turns at this point into something crumbly and incoherent: the remains of what historical buildings are left here neighbor on soviet-era panel "slabs" and structures of a purely utilitarian nature. Recently, such places become increasingly attractive to developers which manifests itself in the growing number of inclusions of modern architecture and even greater quantity of architectural proposals and concepts based upon this idea.

One of such proposals is the project of a residential complex prepared by the studio of Anatoliy Stolyarchuk and due to be implemented at the crossing of Mira and Kotovsky streets. The project had a fair share of hard luck: first of all, it was the necessity of demolishing (and subsequently restoring the facade of) the historical building designed by Dmitry Krzhyzhanovsky. And, although the old tenement was recognized to be a hazard building and all of the people living in it had long since moved into new apartments, the city preservation activists made repeated attempts to challenge in court the municipality's decision about demolishing it. Second of all, finding an understanding with the customer was also far from easy. 

Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Project, 2014 © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio
Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Project, 2014. Location plan © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Project, 2014. Location plan © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

First about the project itself, though! The authors had a high-responsibility task of "tying in" the new building to the historical one - a humble specimen of Saint Petersburg's tenements with characteristic Art Nouveau features. In town planning terms, the architects were to visually fasten the corner of the crossroads - completely unstructured as yet - and give the amorphous housing a more regular character. The disappearance of the green yard opened up to the Kotovsky Street, will be made up for at the expense of taking down a two-story annex standing in the yard.

The project of Stolyarchuk studio included this recreated historical volume as a part of a balanced composition with an almost symmetrical plan in the shape of giant "double L" stretched hugely apart, this historical volume given the role of one of the risalits. The first floor will perform public functions, just as the two floors of the building along the Kotovsky Street. Higher up, the typical residential floors are situated. At a height of 23 meters, the wall stands out a little: this is where the sightseeing platform for the people living in the loft is situated (the cornice running at a height of 28 meters). Formed by the risalits, the compact yard has two passages in it: along the Mira Street and along the Kotovsky Street.

Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Project, 2014. © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Plan of the 1st floor. Project, 2014 © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Plan of the typical floor. Project, 2014 © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

While the construction plan is to a large extent conditioned by the shape of the land site, the choice of the style for the new building was open and was also the more challenging part because of its Art Nouveau facade. The idea of historical stylization - considering the increase in the scale and considering the overall changes in the composition - was pretty soon discarded by the authors to give way to the modern vocabulary, rather neutral, but still not altogether alien to Krzhizhanovsky's architecture. 

The building's main façade that towers three floors above the old cornice, looks at the Kotovsky Street with its austere gray surface dissected by a graphic pattern of punctured lines. The general symmetry of its axial composition is distracted by a protrusion of one of the side walls of the former tenement adjoining the building's firewall. This corner junction of the two side walls got a design solution based upon the contrast of simple geometric volumes, as well as their texture and color, which perfectly matches the key town-planning part that it is meant to play. Through the corner cutaway of its lateral entrance, the theme of the tenement continues over at the main façade. Considering it dimensions, increased in comparison with its historical neighbor, the authors looked to balance out the overall impression with neutral style and light color of the finish. The part of the main accents here is played by the central arch with a modernized lunette and a red-brick figure stanza uniting the two top floors. Their color and axial position match the central bay window in the Krzhizhanovsky's building. 

Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Project, 2014 © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

Out of the multitude of the existing ways of interacting with the historical context out there, the authors of the project chose the way of, though respectful, equitable and open stylistic dialogue between the modern and the historical. However, it was the style of the building that became the stumbling block in the architects' relationship with the customer, in the result of which the project winning a silver award at "Arkhitekton-2013" was turned down by the customer who then invited a different company to design the project.

This was not how the story ended, however. The "alternative" project fell under hard criticism from the city council: the new designer tried to take the path that Stolyarchuk had originally discarded - meaning, he decorated the new buildings with eclectic "historicism" elements. Ultimately, the customer was forced to turn back to Anatoliy Stolyarchuk for compromise. At the end of the day, Stolyarchuk's studio got the commission for designing the facades and getting them approved in the Committee for City Planning and Architecture and the Committee on State Control, Use and Protection of Historical and Cultural Landmarks. 

Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Development drawing along the Kotovsky Street. Project, 2014 © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Development drawing along the Mira Street. Project, 2014 © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

This story, in spite of its somewhat softened end, is rather sad, and, what's more upsetting, not quite unique. There are lots of cases out there when a customer, upon getting a concept from a renowned company with a long-standing reputation, hands that concept over for further elaboration (or, should we say "fed to the lions", not to put too fine a point on it) to a different company with a task to cut the costs as much as possible. Although in this particular case the situation is a little bit different, it still goes a long way to illustrate just how vulnerable the architect (and, ultimately, the end consumer) is in the face of the overall decline in the demand for high-quality architecture.

The economic crisis did things to the construction schedule but we will hope that the place where once the demolished historical ruin stood will ultimately get a new up-to-date complex keeping the memory of the place and at the same time matching today's standards of what urban environment must be like.
Multiapartment building at Mira Street. Plan of the loft. Project, 2014 © Anatoliy Stolyarchuk Architectural Studio

24 December 2015

Written by:

Irina Bembel
Translated by:
Anton Mizonov
Headlines now
​Dynamics of the Avenue
On Leningrad Avenue, not far away from the Sokol metro station, the construction of the A-Class business center Alcon II has been completed. ADM architects designed the main façade as three volumetric ribbons, as if the busy traffic of the avenue “shook” the matter sending large waves through it.
​Steamer at the Pier
An apartment hotel that looks like a ship with wide decks has been designed for a land plot on a lake shore in Moscow’s South Tushino. This “steamer” house, overlooking the lake and the river port, does indeed look as if it were ready to sail away.
The Magic of Rhythm or Ornament as a Theme
Designed by Sergey Tchoban, the housing complex Veren Place in St. Petersburg is the perfect example of inserting a new building into a historical city, and one the cases of implementing the strategy that the architect presented a few years ago in the book, which he coauthored with Vladimir Sedov, called “30:70. Architecture as a Balance of Forces”.
​Walking on Water
In the nearest future, the Marc Chagall Embankment will be turned into Moscow’s largest riverside park with green promenades, cycling and jogging trails, a spa center on water, a water garden, and sculptural pavilions designed in the spirit of the Russian avant-garde artists of the 1920, and, first of all, Chagall himself. In this issue, we are covering the second-stage project.
​Architectural Laboratory
A-Len has developed and patented the “Perfect Apartments” program, which totally eliminates “bad” apartment layouts. In this article, we are sharing how this program came around, what it is about, who can benefit from it, and how.
​“Architectural Archaeology of the Narkomfin Building”: the Recap
One of the most important events of 2020 has been the completion of the long-awaited restoration of the monument of Soviet avant-garde architecture – the Narkomfin Building, the progenitor of the typology of social housing in this country. The house retained its residential function as the main one, alongside with a number of artifacts and restoration clearances turned into living museum exhibits.
​LIFE on the Setun River
The area in the valley of the Setun River near the Vereiskaya Street got two new blocks of the “LIFE-Kutuzovsky” housing complex, designed by ADM architects. The two new blocks have a retail boulevard of their own, and a small riverside park.
​Celestial Tectonics
Three towers on a podium over the Ramenka River are the new dominant elements on the edge of a Soviet “microdistrict”. Their scale is quite modern: the height is 176 m – almost a skyscraper; the facades are made of glass and steel. Their graceful proportions are emphasized by a strict white grid, and the volumetric composition picks up the diagonal “grid of coordinates” that was once outlined in the southwest of Moscow by the architects of the 1970’s and 1980’s.
Clouds over the Railroad
In the stead of former warehouses near “Lyubertsy-1” station, a new housing complex has been built, which peacefully coexists with the railroad, with the flyover bridge, and with the diverse surrounding scenery, not only dominating over the latter, but improving it.
​Towers in a Forest
The authors of the housing complex “In the Heart of Pushkino” were faced with a difficult task: to preserve the already existing urban forest, at the same time building on it a compound of rather high density. This is how three towers at the edge of the forest appeared with highly developed public spaces in their podiums and graceful “tucks” in the crowning part of the 18-story volumes.
​The Towers of “Sputnik”
Six towers, which make up a large housing complex standing on the bank of the Moskva River at the very start of the Novorizhskoe Highway, provide the answers to a whole number of marketing requirements and meets a whole number of restrictions, offering a simple rhythm and a laconic formula for the houses that the developer preferred to see as “flashy”.
​The Starting Point
In this article, we are reviewing two retro projects: one is 20 years old, the other is 25. One of them is Saint Petersburg’s first-ever townhouse complex; the other became the first example of a high-end residential complex on Krestovsky Island. Both were designed and built by Evgeny Gerasimov and Partners.
The Path to New Ornamentation
The high-end residential complex “Aristocrat” situated next to a pine park at the start of the Rublev Highway presents a new stage of development of Moscow’s decorative historicist architecture: expensively decorated, yet largely based on light-colored tones, and masterfully using the romantic veneer of majolica inserts.
​Renovation: the Far East Style
The competition project of renovating two central city blocks of Yuzhno-Sakhalinsk, developed by UNK project, won the nomination “Architectural and planning solutions of city construction”.
​The Contact
The Istituto Centrale per la Grafica in Rome presents Sergei Tchoban’s exhibition “Imprint of the future. Destiny of Piranesi’s City”. The exhibition includes four etchings, based on Roman architectural views of the XVIII century complemented by futuristic insertions, as well as a lot of drawings that investigate the same topic, at times quite expressively. The exhibition poses questions, but does not seem to give any answers. Since going to Rome is pretty problematic now, let’s at least examine the pictures.
​In Search of Visual Clarity
In this article, we are reviewing a discussion devoted to the question of designing city space elements, which is quite complicated for the Russian expanses of land. The discussion was organized by the Genplan Institute of Moscow at the ArchMoscow convention in Gostiny Dvor.
​The City of the Sun
Jointly designed by Sergey Tchoban and Vladimir Plotkin, the VTB Arena Park complex can arguably be considered the perfect experiment on solving the centuries-old controversy between traditional architecture and modernism. The framework of the design code, combined with the creative character of the plastique-based dialogue between the buildings, formed an all-but-perfect fragment of the city fabric.
​...The Other Was Just Railroad Gin*
In their project of the third stage of “Ligovsky City” housing complex, located in the industrial “gray” belt of Saint Petersburg, the KCAP & Orange Architects & A-Len consortium set before themselves a task of keeping up the genius loci by preserving the contours of the railroad and likening the volumes of residential buildings to railroad containers, stacked up at the goods unloading station.
​Lions on Glass
While reconstructing the facades of Building 4 of Moscow Hospital #23, SPEECH architects applied a technique, already known from Saint Petersburg projects by Sergey Tchoban – cassettes with elements of classical architecture printed on glass. The project was developed gratis, as a help to the hospital.
Park of Sentiments
The project of “Romantic Park Tuchkov Buyan”, which was developed by the consortium of Studio 44 and WEST 8, and has won an international competition, combines sculptural landscape design and wooden structures, variety of spatial features and an eventful agenda, designed for diverse audience, with a beautiful and complex passeist idea of a palace park, meant to evoke thoughts and feelings.
​Architecture as an Educational Tool
The concept of a charity school “Tochka Budushchego” (“Point of the Future”) in Irkutsk is based on cutting-edge educational programs, and is designed, among other things, for adapting orphaned children for independent life. An important role is played by the architecture of the building: its structure and different types of interconnected spaces.
​The Gallery Approach
In this article, we are covering the concept of a Central District Clinic for 240 patients, designed by Ginzburg Architects, which won at a competition organized by the Architects Union and the Healthcare Ministry.
Health Constructor
In this issue, we are publishing the concept of a standard clinic designed by UNK Project, which took second place in the competition organized by the Union of Architects of Russia in collaboration with the Healthcare Ministry.
From Foundation to Teaspoon
Based on the taste of their friendly clients, the architects Olga Budennaya and Roman Leonidov designed and built a house in the Moscow metropolitan area playing Art Nouveau. At the same time, they enriched the typology of a private house with modern functions of a garage loft and a children’s art studio.
Continuation and Development
The second “office” stage of Comcity, the most popular business park of the “New Moscow” area, continues the underground street of the already existing part of the complex, responding to its architectural identity.
​The Flying One
Expected to become an analogue of Moscow’s Skolkovo, the project of the High Park campus at Saint Petersburg’s ITMO University, designed by Studio 44, mesmerizes us with its sheer scale and the passion that the architects poured into it. Its core – the academic center – is interpreted as an avant-garde composition inspired by Piazza del Campo with a bell tower; the park is reminiscent of the “rays” of the main streets of Saint Petersburg, and, if watched from a birds-eye view, the whole complex looks like a motherboard with at least four processors on it. The design of the academic building even displays a few features of a sports arena. The project has a lot of meanings and allusions about it; all of them are united by plastique energy that the hadron collider itself could be jealous of.
​The Aperture Effect
For a housing complex built in the town of Pushkino in the Moscow metropolitan area, KPLN Architects designed facades that adjust the stream of light by using the wall geometry.
​A Comfortable City in Itself
The project that we are about to cover is seemingly impossible amidst human anthills, chaotically interspersed with old semi-neglected dachas. Meanwhile, the housing complex built on the Comcity business part does offer a comfortable environment of decent city: not excessively high-rise and moderately private as a version of the perfect modern urbanist solution.
Moving on the Edge
The housing complex “Litsa” (“Faces”) on Moscow’s Khodynka Field is one of the new grand-scale buildings that complement the construction around it. This particular building skillfully tackles the scale, subjugating it to the silhouette and the pattern; it also makes the most of the combination of a challenging land site and formidable square footage requirements, packing a whole number of features within one volume, so the house becomes an analogue of a city. And, to cap it all, it looks like a family that securely protects the children playing in the yard from... well, from everything, really.
Visual Stability Agent
A comparatively small house standing on the border of the Bolshevik Factory combines two diametrically opposite features: expensive materials and decorative character of Art Deco, and a wide-spaced, even somewhat brutal, facade grid that highlights a laminated attic.
The Faraday Cage
The project of the boutique apartment complex in the 1st Truzhenikov Lane is the architects’ attempt to squeeze a considerable volume into a tiny spot of land, at the same time making it look graceful and respectable. What came to their rescue was metal, stone, and curvilinear glass.
Color and Line
The new successful techniques developed by A.Len for designing a kindergarten under budget constraints: the mosaic of irregular windows and working with color.
The Union of Art and Technology
His interest for architecture of the 1930’s is pretty much the guiding star for Stepan Liphart. In his project of the “Amo” house on St. Petersburg’s Vasilyevsky Island, the architect based himself on Moscow Art Deco - aesthetically intricate and decorated in scratch-work technique. As a bonus, he developed the city block typology as an organic structure.
The Countdown
The project that Evgeniy Gerasimov and Partners developed for Moscow’s Leningrad Avenue: the tallest building in the company’s portfolio, continuing the tradition of Moscow’s Stalin architecture.
White Town
In the project that they developed for a southern region of Russia, OSA Architects use multilayered facades that create an image of seaside resort architecture, and, in the vein of the latest trends of today, mix up different social groups that the residents belong to.
​Just a Mirror for the Sun
The house that Sergey Skuratov designed in Nikolovorobinsky Alley is thought out down to the last detail. It adapts three historical facades, interprets a feeling of a complex city, is composed of many layers, and catches plenty of sunlight, from sunrises to sunsets. The architect himself believes that the main role of this house is creating a background for another nearby project of his, Art House in the Tessinsky Alley.
​Part of the Whole
On June 5, the winners of Moscow Architectural Award were announced. The winners list includes the project of a school in Troitsk for 2,100 students, with its own astronomy dome, IT testing ground, museum, and a greenhouse on the roof.
Pedagogical Architecture
Yet another project of a private school, in which Archimatika realizes the concept of aesthetic education and introduces a new tradition: combining Scandinavian and Soviet experience, turning to works of art, and implementing sustainable technologies.
​Rational Arrangement
In this article, we are examining a complex of buildings and interiors of the first stage of the project that has recently become extremely popular – the Kommunarka clinic.
​Parallel Universe
In the “Parallel House” residence that he designed in the Moscow metropolitan area, the architect Roman Leonidov created a dramatic sculptural composition from totally basic shapes – parallelepipeds, whose collision turned into an exciting show.
In the Istra district of Moscow metropolitan area, the tandem of 4izmerenie and ARS-ST designed a sports complex – a monovolume that has the shape of a chamfered parallelepiped with a pointed “nose” like a ship’s bow.
​Stairway to Heaven
The project of a hotel in the settlement of Yantarny is an example of a new recreational complex typology, and a new format that unites the hotel, the business, and the cultural functions. All of this is complemented by 100% integration with nature.
​Cape of Good Hope
In this issue, we are showing all the seven projects that participated in a closed-door competition to create a concept for the headquarters of Gazprom Neft, as well as provide expert opinions on those projects.